Skip to content
Map of New York eviction risk by county

Property Tax Rate in New York 2025

Effective rate, median annual bill, homestead exemption, and assessment cap rules under N.Y. RPTL § 425

1.40% Effective property tax rate
$6,303 Median annual bill (ACS 2022)
137% Of U.S. national median
2% annual levy cap Annual assessment cap
Homestead exemption: STAR (School Tax Relief): Basic $30,000 income < $500k; Enhanced for 65+ with income < $93,200 exempts ~$77,700 of school taxes.
Statutory authority: N.Y. RPTL § 425

What the median New York homeowner pays

Median annual property tax (ACS 2022, B25103)$6,303
= Median monthly property tax$525
Effective rate (Tax Foundation 2024)1.40%
Tax per $100,000 of home value$1,400

Median bill is the actual ACS 2022 figure for owner-occupied housing units in New York. Your specific bill will vary by county and municipality, local mill rates can swing the effective rate by 30%+ within a single state.

Property tax is usually the single largest fixed cost on a New York rental, and it behaves differently than the tax on a home you live in. New York's effective property tax rate runs about 1.30% of value statewide, above the roughly 1.08% national average but well under high-tax neighbors like New Jersey (2.49%) and Connecticut (2.15%). The rate is only half the story for landlords: rental buildings are assessed on a different basis than owner-occupied homes, and the exemptions that cut a homeowner's bill do not reach you.

New York's effective property tax rate in context

The Tax Foundation puts New York's effective property tax rate at about 1.30% of value for 2026, measured against owner-occupied housing. That sits above the national average of roughly 1.08%, but New York is not among the worst offenders: New Jersey (2.49%), Illinois (2.27%), and Connecticut (2.15%) all run considerably higher.

A statewide average hides enormous local variation. New York funds schools, counties, towns, and special districts largely through property tax, so two buildings with identical market value can carry very different bills depending on the jurisdiction and its levy. Treat the 1.30% figure as a planning anchor for the state as a whole, not as the number that will appear on any single building's bill.

How rental property is assessed, income, not sale price

This is where New York departs sharply from most states. Owner-occupied one-to-three-family homes are one class of property; larger rental buildings, co-ops, and condos are a separate class. In New York City, that separate class. Class 2, is not valued on what the building would sell for. Under state law, income-producing property is assessed by the income-capitalization approach: the Department of Finance looks at the rents you collect, subtracts operating expenses, and capitalizes the resulting net operating income into a value.

Owners of larger buildings feed that process directly. Real Property Income and Expense (RPIE) statements you file each year are the raw material the assessor uses, and buildings with 11 or more units are valued primarily on their reported net operating income. New York City then applies a target assessment ratio of 45% of market value to Class 2 property before the tax rate is applied. The practical takeaway: raising rents can raise your assessed value, and your own filings drive the number.

The homestead gap: exemptions landlords don't get

New York's marquee property tax relief is the School Tax Relief (STAR) program, and it is built exclusively for owner-occupants. Basic STAR exempts $30,000 of a primary residence's value from school taxes for owners with income up to $500,000. Enhanced STAR gives a larger break to owners 65 and older with 2026 income up to $98,700.

None of it reaches a rental. STAR, and the residential exemptions that work like a homestead reduction, all require the property to be the owner's primary residence. Rental buildings, second homes, and investment condos are excluded. That is the owner-occupancy gap in plain terms: the house next door may carry a materially lower effective bill than your identical rental simply because someone lives in it. Budget as though no residential exemption applies, because on a pure investment property, none does.

What it means for a landlord's returns

Because New York taxes rentals on income and denies them homeowner exemptions, property tax lands squarely inside your net operating income, the number lenders and buyers use to value the building. A higher assessment doesn't just raise a bill; it compresses the NOI that sets your cap-rate valuation. The national affordability rule of thumb, housing costs at or below 30% of a tenant's gross income, caps how much of a tax increase you can realistically pass through in rent, and in rent-regulated units you often cannot pass it through at all.

The defensible move is to treat the assessment as contestable. Since the city builds Class 2 value from your own income and expense reporting, accurate, complete RPIE filings and a documented expense picture are your first line of defense, followed by the formal assessment-review process where the numbers don't reflect reality.

Investor warning: New York's 2% annual levy cap applies only to owner-occupied primary residences. When you acquire a property as a non-owner-occupant rental, the cap typically does NOT apply, and the property may be reassessed to current market value at transfer. Build the post-transfer reassessment into your year-1 underwriting.

Homestead Exemption Detail for New York

STAR (School Tax Relief): Basic $30,000 income < $500k; Enhanced for 65+ with income < $93,200 exempts ~$77,700 of school taxes.

The exemption is granted under N.Y. RPTL § 425. To claim it, owner-occupants must typically file an application with the county assessor (most states require filing once, with renewal triggered only by change of ownership or use). Failure to file the application means full taxation at the non-homestead rate.

How New York Compares Nationally

Sources & Methodology

Related Guides for New York Landlords

This page summarizes New York property tax as it applies to rental owners using primary public sources: the Tax Foundation's 2026 state property tax data for effective-rate comparisons, the New York City Department of Finance's Class 2 assessment guidance and Real Property Income and Expense (RPIE) framework for how rental buildings are valued, and the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance for STAR and residential exemption eligibility. Figures reflect 2026 values where a year is specified. Property tax rates, assessment ratios, and exemption limits vary by jurisdiction and change over time; verify current figures with your local assessor or the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, and consult a tax professional before relying on these numbers for a specific property.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is New York's property tax rate for rental property?

There is no separate published rate for rentals. New York's effective property tax rate averages about 1.30% of value statewide for 2026 (Tax Foundation), above the roughly 1.08% national average. The actual bill on any building depends on local levies and, in New York City, on how the building's income-based assessment is set.

How is a rental building assessed in New York?

Rental buildings are income-producing property. Under state law they are valued by the income-capitalization approach, rents minus operating expenses, capitalized into value, rather than on sale price. In New York City these are Class 2 properties, assessed at a target ratio of 45% of market value, with buildings of 11+ units valued largely on the net operating income you report on RPIE statements.

Can a landlord claim STAR or a homestead exemption in New York?

No. STAR and residential homestead-type exemptions require the property to be the owner's primary residence. Basic STAR exempts $30,000 of value from school taxes for owner-occupants (income up to $500,000), and Enhanced STAR helps owners 65+ (2026 income up to $98,700), but neither applies to a rental or a second home.

Is New York's property tax rate high compared to other states?

It is above average but not the highest. At about 1.30%, New York exceeds the roughly 1.08% U.S. average, yet trails New Jersey (2.49%), Illinois (2.27%), and Connecticut (2.15%), which rank among the highest in the country (Tax Foundation, 2026).

Why does raising rents increase my New York property tax?

Because New York City values Class 2 rental property on its income. The Department of Finance builds your assessment from the net operating income reported on your RPIE statements, so higher rents and lower expenses can raise assessed value, and therefore your tax, in a way that does not happen for owner-occupied homes assessed on sale-comparable value.

How does property tax affect a rental's value and returns?

Property tax is a fixed operating cost that reduces net operating income, the figure used to value the building at a given cap rate. A higher assessment lowers NOI and, with it, the building's market value. In rent-regulated units you may be unable to pass increases through, so the tax comes straight out of your return.

Effective rate source: Tax Foundation analysis of Census ACS 2022 (published 2024). Statutory citation: N.Y. RPTL § 425. Last updated November 21, 2026. For informational purposes only, not tax or legal advice. Consult a CPA or tax attorney for your specific situation.