Sibley County, Minnesota Eviction Risk: Moderate
6 incorporated cities and unincorporated areas. The county Eviction Risk Score is held aloft by the city of Gaylord (4.5) and a small number of dense urban cores. Rent-control coverage varies by city.
Ranked #45 of 87 MN counties
8k residents · 6 cities · 4 tracts
Sibley County eviction risk score history
Key metrics
-
Tenant beats landlord35.2%/ 100 outcomesIn court-decided eviction outcomes for Sibley County, MN, tenants prevail in roughly 35.2% of contested cases. A higher number means landlords face stronger tenant defenses and longer calendars.
-
Timeline95dfiling → judgmentFrom the moment an unlawful-detainer notice is filed in Sibley County, MN until a money judgment is entered, a contested eviction takes about 95 days on average. Longer timelines mean more lost rent for landlords.
-
Cost range$4.2–9.5klegal + lost rentA typical eviction in Sibley County, MN costs landlords $4,167 to $9,523 all-in, covering court filing fees, process-server costs, attorney time, and lost rent.
-
Average rent$77327% stretched on rentAverage gross rent in Sibley County, MN is $773 per month per the U.S. Census American Community Survey. 27% of renter households here spend more than 30% of pre-tax income on rent.
-
Renters28.4%of households28.4% of occupied housing units in Sibley County, MN are renter-occupied. A higher renter share usually correlates with more eviction filings and a more active rental market.
-
Poverty13.1%4.8% unemp.13.1% of Sibley County, MN residents live below the federal poverty line, and unemployment runs at 4.8%. Both feed the economic-stress sub-score in our Eviction Risk Score model.
Scrub 50 years
Sibley County averages 4/10 (Moderate) across 6 tracked cities, ranging from 4/10 in Arlington, Winthrop, and Henderson to 4/10 in Gaylord. Ranked 66th of 87 Minnesota counties - lower-risk third of the state.
How Sibley County ranks in Minnesota
Landlord guides for Minnesota
| City↕ | Population↕ | Risk↕ | % income on rent↕ | Average rent↕ | Lean↕ | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 001 | Gaylord | 2,073 | 4.5 | 34.5% | $860 | Rep |
| 002 | Arlington | 2,065 | 4.0 | 27.4% | $549 | Rep |
| 003 | Winthrop | 1,381 | 3.5 | 21.8% | $776 | Rep |
| 004 | Gibbon | 918 | 4.0 | 20.7% | $950 | Rep |
| 005 | Henderson | 875 | 3.6 | 16.9% | $923 | Rep |
| 006 | New Auburn | 436 | 3.8 | 31.4% | $738 | Rep |
County heatmap
One county, multiple regulatory regimes.
Sibley County sits in the lower-risk third of Minnesota eviction laws's 87 counties, carrying an average eviction risk score of 4/10 (Moderate) and ranking 66th statewide, meaning 65 counties present higher risk to landlords. That position reflects a rental market shaped by small-town economics: average rent of $773 per month, a rent burden rate of 26.5%, and a renter share of 28.4% of households, all well below Twin Cities-metro levels. With a total population of roughly 7,748 and a poverty rate of 13.1%, the county's risk profile is driven less by tenant-protection legislation and more by household income constraints that can make rent difficult to sustain during income disruptions.
The county's six tracked cities span a narrow range of 4.5 to 4/10. Gaylord (population 2,073) is the county seat and posts the highest score at 4.5/10, while Gibbon and New Auburn each register 3.8/10. Arlington (population 2,065), Winthrop, and Henderson all land at 3.6/10, the county floor. Landlords operating across multiple Sibley cities should note that even the lower-scoring cities carry a moderate designation - no city in the county falls into a low-risk band. The tight scoring range (4.5 to 5) signals fairly uniform underlying conditions across this rural market rather than one outlier city driving the county average.
Minnesota eviction laws's landlord-tenant framework under Minn. Stat. § 504B (Landlord and Tenant) governs all Sibley County properties. Nonpayment evictions require a 14-day notice under Minn. Stat. § 504B.291, while material lease violations and month-to-month terminations each require 30 days under Minn. Stat. § 504B.135. Court filing fees run $310 to $410, and an uncontested case typically resolves in 30 to 60 days - though contested matters can stretch to 150 days. Attorney fees in Minnesota eviction laws eviction cases commonly range from $750 to $3,000, which in a county with $773 average rents can represent multiple months of gross rent. Landlords should also be aware that Minnesota eviction laws protects source of income as a fair housing category, enforced through the Minnesota Department of Human Rights; a Section 8 or voucher applicant cannot be turned away on that basis alone. There is no state rent cap and no just-cause eviction requirement in Sibley County, and Minnesota eviction laws's statute does not preempt local rent control ordinances, though no Sibley municipality has enacted one.
Sibley County's moderate risk score reflects a small rural rental market where limited tenant-protection ordinances keep statutory risk lower than urban Minnesota eviction laws counties, but a 13.1% poverty rate and 26.5% rent burden mean cash-flow disruptions are a recurring reality for landlords and renters alike.
Eviction filings in Minnesota
The Princeton Eviction Lab Tracking System covers Minnesota statewide (no county-level tracker available for Sibley County). In the past month, 2,011 statewide filings were recorded, 1.03× the historical baseline (near baseline).
- 2,011Past month (state)
- 26,070Past 12 months
- 1.07×vs baseline (12 mo)
Eviction filings in Sibley County
In August 2025, 2 eviction filings were recorded in Sibley County, 66.7% of the historical average (below average).2
- 2Aug 2025
- 66.7%of historical avg
- 1,102Renter households
- 9.9%Poverty rate
Historical eviction filings in Sibley County
From 2009 to 2018, eviction filings in Sibley County increased 30%. The peak was 26 filings in 2011.3
- 102009
- 26Peak (2011)
- 132018
Data covers 2000–2018, the full span of the Princeton Eviction Lab's national county court-records dataset.
How Sibley County compares
Sibley County's 4/10 score matches a cluster of similarly sized rural Minnesota counties - Cass, Stevens, Pennington, and Roseau counties all sit at 4/10 as well, and Faribault County is just a fraction higher at 4/10, placing Sibley solidly in the moderate tier alongside these agricultural and small-town markets rather than the higher-risk metro-adjacent counties that dominate Minnesota's top-20 riskiest.