Skip to content
Neighborhood · Indianapolis, IN

Otterbein Eviction Risk: Moderate

3 census tracts · pop 6,909 · pop-weighted Eviction Risk Score 5.1/10 · range 4.7–5.4

Otterbein is a 3-tract neighborhood of Indianapolis, IN, population 6,909. Scored across those inputs it reaches 5.1/10, placing it in the Moderate tier. 54% of renters here are cost-burdened at the 30% threshold, far above the Indianapolis rate of 30.4%.

What pushes the score up most is tenant-organizing strength at 8.7/10. Annualized rent equals 36% of average household income here, past the 30% affordability line, which compresses the margin any screening standard has to work with.

Severe burden reaches 22%. A tenant at that level absorbs no shock: one cut shift or one repair bill converts directly into arrears. CDC survey data puts housing insecurity at 26.8% of adults, against 14.2% nationally. On the softer side is eviction-process difficulty, at 2.1/10.

SNAP participation is 30.3% of households versus 15.2% nationally. The poverty rate is 22%. Judgments in high-poverty tracts are collectible far less often than the filing statistics suggest.

Well under the midpoint is supply constraint, at 3/10. At $1,023 a month, rents sit 12% under what the rest of Indianapolis commands.

That places it #15 of 76 neighborhoods in Indianapolis. The closest comparables inside the same city are Willard Park and Old Southside.

Social vulnerability runs high at 8.4/10, concentrating the disaster- and displacement-exposure this model treats as a lagging risk input. Its 3 tracts score within 0.7 points of one another, so the area figure travels well to individual addresses.

With little internal variation, 5.1/10 is a fair proxy for any address inside the boundary. Scores move when the ACS release, the court-record feed, or the statute ledger behind them moves.

Risk score
5.1
Moderate
3 tracts · population-weighted
Otterbein vs Indianapolis How this neighborhood stacks against the citywide average
% of income on rent
53.7% +77%
Indianapolis: 30.4%
Average gross rent
$1,023 -12%
Indianapolis: $1,156
Average HH income
$34,352 -45%
Indianapolis: $62,995
Poverty rate
22.0% +40%
Indianapolis: 15.7%
Renter share
63.9% +45%
Indianapolis: 44.0%
Peer neighborhoods

Neighborhoods with similar eviction risk

Same county, closest by Eviction Risk Score.

Geographic context

Risk heat across Otterbein and the region

Click any tract to drill in · 3 tracts span score 4.7–5.4

Why Otterbein scores 5.1

9 axes · pop-weighted · 1 = landlord-friendly
State political climate
legislature & governorship · Range 2.0–2.0 across tracts
2.0
Regional political climate
County-level mix · 2024 presidential margin · Range 6.5–6.5 across tracts
6.5
Local political climate
Parent city governance · Range 6.8–6.8 across tracts
6.8
Rent control risk
54% of income on rent · Range 6.6–6.6 across tracts
6.6
Eviction process difficulty
State notice requirements & court backlog · Range 2.1–2.1 across tracts
2.1
Tenant organizing strength
64% renter households · Range 8.7–8.7 across tracts
8.7
Housing court bias
County bench composition · Range 6.8–6.8 across tracts
6.8
Economic stress
22.0% below poverty line · Range 3.6–8.6 across tracts
5.5
Supply constraint
Rent-to-FMR gap & zoning friction · Range 2.1–3.6 across tracts
3.0
Risk score comparison

Otterbein vs. parent city, state, U.S.

Eviction Risk Score (0–10 scale).

Otterbein score vs. parent city, state, U.S.5.1OtterbeinNeighborhood4.0Parent cityhost city3.7Stateavg in state5.1U.S.national avgU.S. avg = 5.0
Variance across tracts

How uniformly does eviction risk play out in Otterbein?

Left: distribution of constituent tract scores. Right: every tract as a heat square. Click any square to drill in.

Score distribution
0246810
Spread of 0.7 points from 4.7 to 5.4. Tracts are relatively uniform, so conditions feel similar throughout the neighborhood.
Tracts as heat grid
Each square = one census tract. Color tracks the same green→red ramp as the chloropleth map above.
Census tracts

3 tracts in Otterbein

Ranked highest-risk first. Click for per-tract detail.

Tract Score Pop % over 30% on rent Average rent
18097360101 5.4 2,402 57% $909
18097352300 5.4 1,186 49% $1,031
18097352400 4.7 3,321 53% $1,103
Social Vulnerability Index

CDC SVI percentile: 81

Pop-weighted across 3 tracts. Higher = more vulnerable to disaster, displacement, and rent shocks. Source: CDC/ATSDR SVI 2022.

Socioeconomic status 92%ile
Poverty, unemployment, no-HS-diploma, housing cost burden
Household characteristics 87%ile
Single-parent HH, disability, language barriers, age 17- / 65+
Racial/ethnic minority 79%ile
Hispanic + non-white share of population
Housing & transport 31%ile
Multi-unit structures, mobile homes, crowding, no vehicle
Eviction filings · Princeton Eviction Lab

Court-record eviction history in Otterbein

Aggregated across 0 validated constituent tracts. Filing rate is filings per 100 renter households, pop-weighted.

Pandemic-era tracking (2020–2021)

  • 1,644Total filings 2020-21
  • 8.1Avg monthly observed
  • 10.6Pre-pandemic baseline
  • 0.75×Ratio to baseline

Pandemic filings ran below baseline. Tracked under Eviction Lab Eviction Tracking System (Indianapolis, IN).

CDC PLACES 2023 · pop-weighted

Eviction-adjacent indicators in Otterbein

Average across all constituent tracts, population-weighted. Source: CDC PLACES (cwsq-ngmh) crude prevalence.

Frequently asked

About Otterbein

Q1

What is the eviction-risk score for Otterbein?

Otterbein scores 5.1/10 (Moderate tier) across 3 census tracts. The pop-weighted Eviction Risk Score blends state law, county filing rates, parent-city politics, and tract-specific rent-to-income and poverty signals.
Q2

How does Otterbein compare to Indianapolis overall?

Otterbein scores 1.1 points higher than Indianapolis overall (4/10). Renters spend 54% of income on rent vs 30% citywide. Average rent: $1,023 vs $1,156.
Q3

What is the average rent in Otterbein?

Average gross rent in Otterbein is $1,023/month (pop-weighted across 3 census tracts, ACS 5-year 2023). 54% of renter households are cost-burdened.
Q4

What percentage of Otterbein residents are renters?

64% of Otterbein households are renter-occupied (vs 44% in Indianapolis). The neighborhood has 6,909 residents.
Q5

Is Otterbein a high social-vulnerability area?

Otterbein sits in the 81st percentile nationally on the CDC Social Vulnerability Index (highly vulnerable). The index combines poverty, unemployment, household composition, racial/ethnic minority share, and housing/transportation factors across all US census tracts.
Q6

Which tracts in Otterbein have the highest eviction risk?

The highest-risk constituent tract in Otterbein is census tract 18097360101 (score 5.4/10). Across the 3 tracts in this neighborhood the score ranges from 4.7 to 5.4, a spread of 0.7 points.
Q7

How safe is Otterbein for landlords?

Otterbein carries a moderate-tier eviction-risk profile for landlords (5.1/10). Pop-weighted across 3 constituent tracts, the score blends parent-city rent-control posture, county eviction-process timelines, and tract-specific rent-to-income / poverty signals. Compared to Indianapolis as a whole (4/10), this neighborhood is higher-risk.
Q8

What is the demographic breakdown of Otterbein?

Otterbein has 7,032 residents. Top groups: Black (non-Hispanic) (55.7%), White (non-Hispanic) (28.4%), Hispanic / Latino (10.6%). Source: ACS 5-year 2023, table B03002.
Nearby

Other neighborhoods near Otterbein

Sibling neighborhoods

Other neighborhoods inside Indianapolis

Same parent city, ranked by score similarity to Otterbein.

Zoom out

Up the geography chain · or explore further